Men can't rate other men as accurately as needed. Women's subconscious ratings would differ from ours and someone who is rated as 7 by us could be considered as 5 by most women.
You can't ask women to give a rating as it would be inaccurate. Giving them certain amount of pics of men and asking them to place them in order of attractiveness could be legit though.
well its a rating system clearly from men for men.
we already know that women find 80% of men disgusting subhumans. i wish it was an overstatement, but it isnt.
a while back some sluts rated some sluthate users...i think 2 or 3 guys out of 30 or 40 were considered goodlooking