They arrive age 18, at their college freshman dorm. First guy is 6'3" 200lbs, second guy is 5'8" 120lbs. I would predict instant centre of attention/high status for the jock, and very cold one word answer reactions from people towards the nerd. Jock would slay 3-4 girls in the first 2 weeks, and would fall in with a cool social circle of chads and chadettes. Nerd would be unspokenly excluded and forced out of any social interactions, eventually would fall in with an aspie minecraft incel crew of fellow ugly guys.